Are Carbs More Addictive Than Cocaine?

Calking
on 6/8/13 4:53 am
VSG on 05/31/12

 

Isn’t it a bit unnerving that doctors call what they do their “practice”?  -  George Carlin             

 

busboss1
on 6/8/13 5:05 am
VSG on 12/18/12

YES! At least sugar is, in my opinion! I haven't read the article but I'm going to here as soon as I'm done writing this response! Ha.

   Starting weight-244.4   Currently-145.2   Surgeon goal-150   My own goal-140        

      

     

    
Diana E.
on 6/8/13 5:08 am
VSG on 03/27/13

Without first reading the article.. base on personal experience, YES.  Without a doubt.  If I was told I would be skinny, but can only eat pasta, bread, corn and potatoes for the rest of my life.... I would be quite certain I had died and gone to heaven.

HW- 318    SW- 310    CW- 194.4    GW- 170-ish  Onderland: 10/30/2013

   

    

    

VSG on 06/12/13
Thank you for this. I face booked it, as well.

   

Sleeved 6/12/13 - 100 pounds lost to get to goal!

Julia HasHerLifeNow
on 6/8/13 5:37 am
VSG on 10/09/12

I don't know....never tried cocaine! But good article, definitely. All the NUTs out there who continue to stand by the minimum number of grs of carbs (usually over 100!) a day that we need to avoid our brains from shutting down need to read this.

View more of my photos at ObesityHelp.com 5ft0; highest weight 222; surgery weight 208; current weight 120

     

    

KathyA999
on 6/8/13 7:05 am

Well, I've done both in my time, and a goodly amount...  I went back to carbs.  Just sayin!

Height 5' 7"   High Wt 268 / Consult Wt 246 / Surgery Wt 241 / Goal Wt 150 / Happy place 135-137 / Current Wt 143
Tracker starts at consult weight       
                               
In maintenance since December 2011.
 

Imakitekat
on 6/8/13 7:11 am - ID
VSG on 09/23/13
Great article! Scary isn't it?
Lisa
jubjub
on 6/8/13 9:06 am - Palm Desert, CA
VSG on 06/25/12

I think it's worth pointing out that there are two (at least, but lets simplify) kinds of carbs:

1. Carbs that exist in their natural state - inside of a real food like broccoli  - something hopefully not overly bread for sweetness (like most fruit) by the hand of humans

2. Carbs that exist well outside of their natural state, like granulated sugar, flour, juices, etc.

I don't think category 1 is addictive - as Lustig points out, carbs in most natural foods are surrounded by fiber that slow down the digestion process.  The harm seems to come from free floating carbs (mostly category 2 carb foods where the digestion process is very fast, leading to pushing reward buttons in the brain, and then the damage done by insulin spikes, etc.

 

 

Heaviest: 313/VSG Pre: 295/Surgery: 260/Maintenance target:190 - Recent: 195 (08/15/19)

1st 2015&2016 12-Hour Time Trial UMCA 50-59 Age Group
1st 2017 Race Across the West 4-Person 50-59 Age Group
4th 2019 Race Across America 8 Person Team

linzeelee
on 6/8/13 11:41 am - Omaha, NE
VSG on 05/17/13
"Intrusive thoughts when you go too long without a fix."

I've said for a long time that I get food stuck in my head like normal people get songs stuck in theirs. I used to think about carbs constantly. Since my low carb pre op diet, I've had a dradtic reduction in those thoughts. Love it.

Lindsay ~ 5'4" ~ HW (5/6/13): 280 ~ SW (5/17/13): 273 ~ CW: 140
Losses by month: pre-op: -8  M1: -18  M2: -12  M3: -13  M4: -9  M5: -10  M6: -12
  M7: -14  M8: -12  M9: -2  M10: -8  M11: -9  M12: -2  M13: -6  M14: -7

   

busboss1
on 6/8/13 11:51 am
VSG on 12/18/12

I've discussed this with a therapist! The fact if I think about carbs in the evening after dinner, I can't stop myself from eating them. I have never had an addiction to drugs but I can imagine if the feeling is the same as I feel for carbs after dinner, it's terrible. The article is fantastic but scary at the same time. I want to share it with my daughter and granddaughter's Mom!

I have had the surgery and I am losing weight so I don't eat many carbs anymore. I do find if I make a choice to eat a piece of cake or some other sweet, I crave them. Now I know why. It really is an addiction.

   Starting weight-244.4   Currently-145.2   Surgeon goal-150   My own goal-140        

      

     

    
Most Active
Recent Topics
Pain
michele1 · 3 replies · 72 views
Expired Optifast Question
Freewheeler · 2 replies · 269 views
Back - AGAIN - 14+ years post-op
Stacy160 · 4 replies · 329 views
×